Season 6 Ep #5 Shaolin Secrets: Wu-Tang Clan’s One-Of-A-Kind Album Could Rewrite Music Law

What happens when one of the most legendary hip-hop collectives of all time turns its art into a first-of-its-kind legal case? In this episode of IP Goes Pop!, hosts Michael Snyder and Joseph Gushue enter into the legal and ongoing cultural journey behind Wu-Tang Clan’s infamous one-of-a-kind album, Once Upon a Time in Shaolin. What began as a creative experiment in artistic exclusivity could become a landmark case in modern intellectual property (IP) law that could alter how musical recordings can be protected.

What happens when one of the most legendary hip-hop collectives of all time turns its art into a first-of-its-kind legal case? In this episode of IP Goes Pop!, hosts Michael Snyder and Joseph Gushue enter into the legal and ongoing journey behind Wu-Tang Clan’s infamous one-of-a-kind album, Once Upon a Time in Shaolin. What began as a creative experiment in artistic exclusivity could become a landmark case in modern intellectual property (IP) law that could alter how musical recordings can be protected.

The story begins in Staten Island, where Wu-Tang Clan fused martial arts mythos with hip-hop mastery. Fast-forward to 2015, when the group secretly records and auctions off a single physical copy of the album Once Upon a Time in Shaolin, with a contract so restrictive that it reads more like an ancient riddle than a sales contract. The album passes through the hands of a notorious pharma executive, the U.S. Marshals Service, and then eventually finds a home in PleasrDAO, a blockchain collective that currently owns the work and must follow the restrictions as set forth in the terms of sale.

Michael and Joe unpack how this album, intended to be heard by a select few, is now central to a lawsuit exploring whether music can, in certain circumstances, qualify as a trade secret under the Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA). The hosts explore why secrecy itself can sometimes be the source of value in intellectual property, how first sale and copyright doctrines fall short in this unique context, and what artists and collectors can learn about crafting contracts that merge art, technology, and exclusivity.

Listeners will hear how Wu-Tang’s creative vision blurred the line between sound recording and the exclusivity of fine art, why blockchain-backed ownership matters for future IP rights, and what the courts are saying about the “economic value of secrecy.” Along the way, Michael and Joe reference everything from the Banksy self-shredding painting to the Coca-Cola formula, showing how possibly the rarest album ever made could help reshape how we think about protecting music, data, and collectibles.

Whether you’re an artist curious about protecting exclusive content, a lawyer intrigued by novel IP theories, or simply a disciple of the Wu-Tang who loves a good legal saga, this episode delivers sharp analysis and a touch of tiger-style storytelling.

In short: Wu-Tang Clan didn’t just have a hand in changing hip-hop, they may have just changed IP law.

Timestamps:

(01:29) Introduction to Wu-Tang Clan Origins in Staten Island, New York (1992)

Largest rap group assembled at the time
Initial album release in 1993: Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers)
Wu-Tang Clan members and their roles
- RZA aka The Abbot (producer), GZA, Ol’ Dirty Bastard (ODB), Method Man, Raekwon, Ghostface Killah, Inspecktah, Deck, U-God, Masta Killa, Cappadonna (honorary 10th member)
- Group vs. Solo record deals
Chappelle's Show (2007)
Wu-Tang Clan merchandise

(05:14) Once Upon a Time in Shaolin: The Exclusive Album

Mystique behind the seventh studio album by Wu-Tang Clan
Unique Restrictions on the Album
- Copyrights, commercial use, resale, personal use by owner, timeline on album restrictions, etc.

(10:06) The Album's Ownership Journey

Auctioned in 2015
- Winning bid by Martin Shkreli for $2 million
Seized by the US Marshals Service, sold in a forfeiture sale
- PleaserDAO (finalized in 2021)

(15:14) Exhibition of Album at the Museum of Old and New Art (MONA)

10-day showcase in Tasmania (June 2024) in compliance with the album’s restrictions
Limited listening sessions
High demand for free tickets

(17:21) Current Legal Battle: PleaserDAO vs. Martin Shkreli (2025)

Lawsuit for misappropriation of a trade secret due to alleged unauthorized streaming and sharing
Trade Secret Episodes of IP Goes Pop!
- Intellectual Property Urban Legends: Taking on Myths About IP in Popular Culture
- You Can't Do That: What IP Cannot Protect
Novelty of Trade Secret Protection for Music
The difference between copyrights and trade secret protection
First sale doctrine and licensing restrictions

(21:47) Court's Evaluation of Trade Secret Claim

Integrated Cash Management factors
PleaserDAO's business model of exclusivity
Independent economic value from secrecy
Banksy Shredding Art Work
Coca-Cola recipe (or formula)

(27:23) Rap Genre's Contributions to IP Law

2 Live Crew's Banned in the USA parody case (Supreme Court)
Wu-Tang Clan's novel application of trade secret protection

(28:44) Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA)

Federal cause of action for trade secrets vs. state only
Sound as a trade secret

(29:56) Final Thoughts

Wu-Tang Clan's ongoing impact on IP law
Potential future developments in AI and music ownership

Attorneys

Practices

Copyrights

Related Podcasts

Ep #2: Intellectual Property Urban Legends -Taking on Myths About IP in Popular Culture
06.24.2020
This week on IP Goes Pop!, Joseph Gushue, Shareholder with Volpe Koenig, joins fellow Shareholder Michael Snyder to talk about IP “urban legends.” What is an IP urban legend? That would be misinformation circulating about patents, trademarks, copyrights, or trade secrets that sounds right, but is not quite right (certainly not from a legal standpoint).
Season 3 Ep #11- You Can't Do That-What IP Cannot Protect
12.07.2022
Who holds the patent on gravity? Who collects the royalties for the speed of light? In this episode of IP Goes Pop!, Volpe Koenig Shareholders and podcasts hosts, Michael Snyder and Joseph Gushue, explore what intellectual property (trade secrets, trademarks, patents and copyrights) cannot protect. Hint- some things excluded from IP protection include the Laws of Nature such as gravity, the speed of light and even Einstein’s theory of relativity E=MC2. Abstract ideas are another. But what other “can’t”s stand between you, your idea, and protections for it?

To set the table, this episode begins with a pop culture journey through famous “Can’t” songs and movies. Moving into the intellectual property segment of the show your hosts explore the question ‘Why can't intellectual property rights protect everything?’

In some ways, in order to understand what you can protect you first need to learn what you cannot protect. Intellectual property rights are designed to protect concepts like ideas, inventions, creative works, processes and methods, formulas, brand names, and more. Intellectual property rights cannot be used to protect other concepts like mathematical algorithms and natural phenomenon. Also, with the possible exceptions of trade secrets (if kept secret) and trademarks (if continuously used), intellectual property rights are limited in scope and duration. In other words, after a patent, trademark or copyright expires or is abandoned, your intellectual property rights are no longer protected.

In this episode, you will learn some nuances of intellectual property law such as legal reverse engineering and proper vs. improper means of acquiring a trade secret.

Michael and Joe break down some of the reasons why some ideas may be better suited for trademark, patent, or copyright protection instead of trade secret protection. If you’ve ever wanted to know what you can and cannot do in the IP world, this episode is for you!