Season 6 Ep #4 From Comics to Court: A Spider-Man Patent Saga

  • Season 6 Ep #4 From Comics to Court: A Spider-Man Patent Saga

    Swing into the world of intellectual property and untangle the legal threads behind legendary wall-crawling comic book character, Spider-Man. From comic book origins to blockbuster films, hosts Michael Snyder and Joseph Gushue trace Spidey’s journey through pop culture, the U.S. Patent Office, and the courtroom.

Swing into the world of intellectual property and untangle the legal threads behind legendary wall-crawling comic book character, Spider-Man. From comic book origins to blockbuster films, hosts Michael Snyder and Joseph Gushue trace Spidey’s journey through pop culture, the U.S. Patent Office, and the courtroom.

The episode opens with the Spider-Man origin story by Stan Lee and Steve Ditko in the early 1960s. Michael and Joe explore the character’s humble beginnings in Amazing Fantasy #15 and discuss the strategic reason behind the hyphen in “Spider-Man”.

As the conversation unfolds, they dive into Sam Raimi’s groundbreaking movies, highlighting Tobey Maguire’s portrayal of “Old Web Head”. Continuing the cinematic timeline, they explore the Andrew Garfield era and the character’s modern-day resurgence in popularity with Tom Holland, marking Spider-Man’s official entry into the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). Michael and Joe examine how each portrayal influenced the character’s intellectual property possibilities and ongoing generational appeal.

Listeners’ “spidey senses” might start tingling upon hearing about a real-life legal drama surrounding a toy web-shooter patented in 1990. This invention became the subject of a legal battle that reached the Supreme Court in 2015 with Kimble v. Marvel Entertainment, LLC,.The hosts break down this decision, explaining its broader significance for patent licensing agreements. They also note Justice Elena Kagan’s clever comic book closer in her opinion, demonstrating that with “great power comes great responsibility”… even in patent rulings.

The episode continues with a deeper look into other intellectual property aspects of the Spider-Man universe. Importantly, the hosts draw key lessons from the Spider-Man saga for structuring effective patent royalty agreements-- insights no patent holder or licensor will want to miss. They explore the critical distinction between patents and “know-how,” share strategies for structuring royalty payments, and examine the benefits of separating patent rights from non-patent rights in licensing deals. Finally, they highlight creative approaches to long-term royalty structures that can help licensors avoid legal pitfalls and maximize value beyond a patent’s expiration.

This episode of the IP Goes Pop! podcast delivers a fresh perspective on intellectual property law through the lens of an iconic superhero. Whether a comic book fan, superhero film buff, or budding entrepreneur, listeners will find plenty to stick to in this deep dive into Spider-Man’s IP.

Episode Timestamps:

 (01:53) Spider-Man's Rich History in Pop Culture

  • Origin and first appearance: Amazing Fantasy #15 (1962)
  • Spider-Man Theme Song from Original Cartoon (YouTube)
  • Stan Lee and Steve Ditko
  • The Amazing Spider-Man comic series (1963)

(05:31) Spider-Man Movies and the Spider-Verse

 

(13:41) The Spider-Man Toy Patent

(20:27) Patent Expiration and Royalty Agreements Timelines

  • Difference in lifetime of patents, trademarks, and copyrights
  • Brulotte v. Thys Co. (1964)
    • Rule on post-expiration patent royalties unlawful
  • Supreme Court's affirmation of the Brulotte rule in Kimble v. Marvel Entertainment, LLC Supreme Court case
    • Patents vs. “know how”

(26:54) Drafting Patent License Agreements

  • Strategies for structuring royalty payments
  • Bobby Bonilla (as an analogy for royalty structures)
  • Separating patent and non-patent rights

(31:16) Peter Parker as an Inventor

(32:19) Final Thoughts on IP Law and Pop Culture

  • The importance of understanding patent license agreements (and all IP agreements)
Jump to Page

By using this site, you agree to our updated Privacy Policy & Disclaimer.